Posts Tagged 'human genus'

Stones and names

Stones and NamesThe new fossil skull from Dmanisi published this week on Science adds again more questions than answers. The specimens from this site, dated to 1.8 My, display a considerable degree of variation, at the same time showing some resemblance with Homo ergaster, H. erectus, H. habilis, and even with the genus Australopithecus. This last individual has massive facial structures, with a very small cranial capacity which even clashes with the common ranges associated with the human genus. Assuming that all the skulls from Dmanisi are members of the same species, and assuming that morphology is a good indicator for the specie level,  the variation at Dmanisi is such that we could lump most of those cited taxa into a single and heterogeneous group. But, of course, there is no reason to think they represent a single species. Most of all, we already know that morphology can be a very bad source of information on species identity. So, why do we paleontologists insist to define species if we know that it is but a meagre speculation? We can put it in nice colours, appealing statistics, and pretty doll-like nicknames. But it is still a personal opinion, not an analytical solution. Of course, we have to call the attention of the media, that’s a good point. But this way paleoanthropology will never be a robust scientific field. If every descriptive study will be associated with firm, striking, and unverifiable statements, we will keep on swinging from one breaking announcement to another, without a solid development of the field. Maybe we have to change a bit the perspective, or even the aims. And maybe we have to focus more on biology and anatomy, their functions, meaning, and evolution, more than keeping on naming rocks.

Advertisements

Frontal curve

Bruner et al., AJPA 2013Modern humans are supposed to have a bulging frontal squama, but little quantitative evidence is available on this topic. Most analyses included the browridge, the rest of the vault, or the whole skull, possibly confounding factors associated with the spatial relationships of the frontal bone with the other cranial elements. After the analyses of the frontal width and of the parietal curve in the human genus, here’s a quantitative approach to the curvature of the frontal squama (Am J Phys Anthropol 2013). Modern humans do actually have a more bulging frontal bone, independently upon orientation or position of the squama. Nonetheless,  there is some overlapping between modern and extinct variation, suggesting caution when dealing with single specimens. Early modern humans display the same degree of frontal curvature than living modern humans.

See also this recent paper:
Athreya S. 2013. The frontal bone in the genus Homo: a survey of functional and phylogenetic sources of variation. J. Anthropol. Sci. 90:59-80. [pdf]


Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

RSS Brain News

RSS Cognitive archaeology

  • Fall 2017 CCA Course Offerings
    The Center for Cognitive Archaeology is offering three exciting classes this semester: Neurocognition of Art, Cognitive Evolution, and Neandertal Cognition. Follow the link below for detailed information. https://www.uccs.edu/~cca/

RSS The Skull Box

  • Eye-brain spatial relationship
    We have just published a new study on the spatial relationship between visual and endocranial structures in adult modern humans, chimpanzees, and fossil humans. The survey was conducted in collaboration with Michael Masters from Montana Tech (USA), who previously hypothesized that, in modern humans, the positioning of the orbits below the frontal lobes coupl […]

RSS Anthropology

RSS Human Evolution

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Neurophilosophy

  • Researchers develop non-invasive deep brain stimulation method
    Researchers at MIT have developed a new method of electrically stimulating deep brain tissues without opening the skullSince 1997, more than 100,000 Parkinson’s Disease patients have been treated with deep brain stimulation (DBS), a surgical technique that involves the implantation of ultra-thin wire electrodes. The implanted device, sometimes referred to as […]

Disclaimer

This blog publishes texts and comments of the author, which can not be referred to institutions or contexts outside of the blog itself. The published material may be partly derived or reported from the Web, and therefore evaluated in the public domain. If some content violates copyright or if it is considered inappropriate, please contact me, to promptly remove it. On the other hand, please cite this source whenever using images or texts from this website.